1:17am:
Why? Because
breastfeeding is not indecent, but the way LiveJournal and SixApart have been treating users with breastfeeding icons is.
One needn't be a nursing mother to be outraged at LJ Abuse's tuptotrephophobic declation that any image that includes a micron of nipple may not be used "in places on the site where one would not reasonably expect to find sexually explicit content" -- nor to wonder, based on that criterion, whether the current ban may spread. It's okay to use breastfeeding icons, even ones that show a little nipple or aureole, in a breastfeeding community, a SixApart vice president told
boob_nazis.
But what about their use elsewhere? In "places .... where one would not reasonably expect to find sexually explicit content"? LiveJournal's ban on so many images from default icons begins to seem but a brief pause (for the waxing of skis, perhaps?) part-way down a very slippery slope. Already, even images of the Madonna are not exempt.
One needn't be personally affected by the policy to be outraged at the suspension, without appeal, of users who decline to change their perfectly innocent default icons. Nor to be outraged at the rudeness and scarcity of the company's responses to customer complaints and even simple requests for clarification.
As GreatestJournal user
Yonmei put it in the new GJ community BFISTD (
Breastfeeding is still the default!):
What do we want?
For SixApart to pay attention. When they bought LiveJournal, Barak Berkowitz and Mena Trott claimed:
Barak Berkowitz (CEO and Chairman of Six Apart’s Board of Directors): "I think the core thing to say here is we're buying LiveJournal for LiveJournal. We're not buying it to turn it into something else. We know what LiveJournal is. The fact that we come from the community should make people convinced that we're not so naive that we don't know exactly what the community is.... The net is, users will question us, and users will be suspicious until they see what we do in real life in real action over a series of months, and we'll have to prove ourselves to them."
Mena Trott (co-founder of SixApart, creator of Movable Type, and TypePad): "We believe in communication. We're doing this because we think LiveJournal has something that's really strong with the community. We feel that that's one of things we are lacking."
Let's communicate with SixApart. They can ignore e-mails; they can ignore letters; they can probably ignore nurse-ins, though anyone who lives near enough in San Francisco, Paris, or Tokyo should definitely give it a try on Tuesday 6th June. What they cannot ignore -- what their bottom line will not let them ignore -- is a drop in numbers of the people using LiveJournal.
Livejournal Statistics record over 10 million as the total number of accounts created since 1999, but that most likely includes accounts deleted or suspended, and certainly includes accounts never used or no longer used. The actual number of active users is more accurately determined by looking at the numbers updating in last 30 days (just over one million), updating in last 7 days (just over 709 000) and updating in past 24 hours (just over 236 000).
I think we can put a dent in those figures if enough of us care enough about getting SixApart to listen.
Before the strike:
* Let SixApart know you're deleting your journal and why you're doing it. Contact information here [main e-mail: contact@sixapart.com].
* If you have a blog off LiveJournal, post about the strike there. (If you comment regularly on any blog or discussion board or mailing list that you think would be interested in the issue of public support for breastfeeding in public, why not post about the strike there, too?)
* Above all, so as not to worry your friends, make a post on your own journal to let them know that you'll be deleting your journal and why you're doing it.
To go on strike, delete your journal for Tuesday 6th June. Your comments made elsewhere will still be visible, but your name will have a strike through it. Because LiveJournal is a global community, the strike should last 48 hours: begin midnight Tuesday in Kamchatka, end midnight Tuesday in Enewetok. ... But really, if enough of us round the world delete before midnight at the start of Tuesday your time, and don't undelete until after midnight at the end of Tuesday, that should put a dent in the figures.
News releases on the dispute are available online at
BlogSpot.com ("Exposing LJ Abuse ...") and
ProMoM.com.
Meanwhile, many people are leaving LJ for good (voluntarily or otherwise).
* If you're one of them, check out
dreamalynn's tutorial,
How to Pack Up & Leave LiveJournal -- yes, you can take it with you.
* If you're one of them, or looking for one of them, check out her opt-in list of
LJ refugees and their GJ identities. (GreatestJournal ~ where I have the same name as on LJ ~ appears to be the destination of choice, in part because it has agreed not to limit breastfeeding icons.)
Step Apart from SixApart on 06/06/06:
Because breastfeeding is not indecent, but LiveJournal's tuptotrephophobic treatment of breastfeeding mothers is.